How to Reduce Closing Costs and Property Taxes in Florida Real Estate

Buying a home in Florida, whether in Sarasota, Charlotte, or Manatee counties, involves more than just the purchase price. The way you structure your offer can significantly impact your closing costs and long-term property taxes. A key factor? Whether broker commissions are included in the sales price. This guide explains how commissions affect taxes and fees, why it matters, and how buyers can save money in the Florida real estate market.

How Sales Price Affects Closing Costs in Florida
In Florida, several closing costs are calculated based on the sales price recorded in the transaction. These include:

• Documentary Stamp Tax: Florida charges 0.70% of the sales price on deeds (for example, $700 per $100,000). Some counties, like Miami-Dade, have additional surtaxes.
• Title Insurance: Rates are tied to the sales price, with higher prices increasing premiums.
• Other Fees: Certain escrow or recording fees may scale with the transaction amount.

When broker commissions (for example, 3% for the buyer’s agent and 3% for the seller’s agent) are included in the sales price, the recorded price increases, inflating these costs. For example, using the current average sales price in Sarasota County of $589,039:

Scenario 1: Commissions Excluded

• Home value: $589,039
• Buyer pays 3% ($17,671.17) to their agent separately, and seller pays 3% ($17,671.17) to their agent separately.
• Sales price: $589,039
  Documentary stamp tax: $4,123.27 ($589,039 × 0.007)

Scenario 2: Commissions Included

• Home value: $589,039
• Sales price includes an initial 6% commission of $35,342.34: $624,381.34
• New 6% commission on $624,381.34: $37,462.88 (3% buyer = $18,731.44, 3% seller = $18,731.44)
• Documentary stamp tax: $4,370.67 ($624,381.34 × 0.007)

Difference: The seller sees an additional $247.40 in documentary stamp tax, while the buyer’s total cost rises by $37,462.88 (the new commission amount). This reflects a $2,120.54 increase in the total commission due to the higher sales price, with $1,060.27 added to each side’s costs (buyer and seller). This compounding effect shows how including commissions in the sales price raises costs for both parties beyond the initial estimate.

Disclaimer: The 3% commission rate used in this example is for illustrative purposes only. Real estate commissions are not set by law, can vary between brokerages, and are negotiable fees in the real estate industry. Buyers and sellers should consult their agents to determine applicable rates and negotiate terms accordingly.

Currently, the buyer can reduce their fees by paying their broker’s compensation directly outside the sales price, while the seller’s compensation to their listing broker is typically handled through the traditional closing process. However, it may be worth exploring whether sellers could also pay their broker’s compensation separately. This could potentially lower the recorded sales price, reducing taxes and fees for both parties. While the exact process for this is unclear and would require industry innovation, it presents an opportunity for sellers to influence overall costs, a topic that warrants further investigation.

By paying the buyer’s agent commission outside the sales price, buyers can reduce these costs by approximately 6% (or the total commission percentage). This strategy requires negotiation and a clear buyer brokerage agreement but can save thousands at closing.

The Long-Term Impact on Property Taxes
Florida’s property taxes are based on the assessed value determined by county appraisers, who rely heavily on recent sales prices as a benchmark. A higher sales price due to included commissions can inflate the assessed value, leading to higher property taxes for as long as you own the home.

Using the example above:

A $589,039 sales price might result in an assessed value close to $589,039 (after homestead exemptions, if applicable).
A $624,381.34 sales price could push the assessed value higher, increasing your annual tax bill.
In Sarasota County, where the 2025 millage rate averages around 12 mills ($12 per $1,000 of assessed value), a $35,342.34 increase in assessed value adds $424.11 per year to your tax bill ($35,342.34 × 0.012). Over 10 years, that’s $4,241.10 in extra taxes—all because commissions were rolled into the sales price.

Why Include Commissions in the Sales Price?
Despite the added costs, some buyers prefer to include commissions in the sales price because:

It allows them to finance the commission through their mortgage, spreading the cost over 30 years.
It simplifies the transaction, as the seller distributes commissions at closing.
However, this convenience comes at a price. Buyers should weigh the upfront savings of paying commissions separately against the ease of financing them, especially if they plan to own the home long-term.

How to Minimize Closing Costs and Property Taxes
To reduce your costs when buying a home in Florida, consider these strategies:

1. Negotiate Commission Structure: Work with your agent to structure offers where you pay their commission separately, keeping the sales price lower.
2. Sign a Buyer Brokerage Agreement: This formalizes your agent’s compensation, giving you leverage to negotiate how it’s paid.
3. Understand Local Tax Rates: Research documentary stamp taxes and millage rates in Sarasota, Charlotte, or Manatee counties to estimate savings.
4. Consult a Local Expert: A knowledgeable agent can guide you through cost-saving options and ensure your offer aligns with your financial goals.
5. Plan for Long-Term Ownership: If you intend to stay in the home for years, prioritizing a lower sales price can yield significant tax savings.

Why Local Expertise Matters
Navigating Florida’s real estate market requires understanding local nuances, from tax rates to negotiation tactics. At Slice of Florida, our team specializes in Sarasota, Charlotte, and Manatee counties, helping buyers minimize costs and secure their dream homes. For more insights on buying smart, check out our guide on understanding Florida real estate costs.

Conclusion: Buy Smart, Save Big
The way you structure your home purchase in Florida can save you thousands at closing and beyond. By keeping broker commissions out of the sales price, you reduce closing costs and future property taxes, putting more money back in your pocket. Whether you’re buying a condo in Sarasota or a family home in Manatee County, work with a trusted local expert to craft a cost-effective offer that aligns with your goals.

For personalized advice and weekly market tips, visit SliceOfFlorida.com or subscribe to The Real Estate Agent Man Podcast.

(941) 894-9800